5 Best Toasters: Top Picks Reviewed

Discover the best toasters. Read our expert-researched guide comparing Breville, KitchenAid, Cuisinart, Mueller and BLACK+DECKER 2-slice toasters on slots, shade control and special functions.

E
EatYay Editorial
*EatYay earns affiliate commissions on qualifying Amazon purchases.
FTC disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Full details on our Affiliate Disclosure page.

All five toasters here toast two slices — the differences are slot width, shade control and the little features that fix breakfast annoyances. The Breville 'A Bit More' adds time mid-cycle and lets you lift and look without cancelling; the KitchenAid uses a manual lever and an extra-deep cavity; the Cuisinart CPT-122 is the compact budget classic; the Mueller's long 1.6-inch slots take artisan loaves; and the BLACK+DECKER is the extra-wide value standard. Morning people building a breakfast corner should pair one with our electric kettles guide.

Shade dials run from 5 to 7 settings. Bagel modes (most here) toast the cut side harder; frozen/defrost modes add time for freezer bread. Every model here has a removable or drop-down crumb tray.

Quick Comparison Table

Image Product Key Feature Buy Now
Breville BTA720XL Bit More Toaster, 2 Slice, Brushed Stainless Steel Breville BTA720XL Bit More Toaster, 2 Slice, Brushed Stainless Steel 🏆 Best Overall 2-slice toaster, brushed stainless steel (model BTA720XL), 1000 watts • 'A Bit More' button adds extra toasting time mid-cycle • 'Lift & Look' lever checks progress without interrupting the cycle Buy Now
KitchenAid 2 Slice Manual Lift Toaster, Stainless Steel (KMT2115SX) KitchenAid 2 Slice Manual Lift Toaster, Stainless Steel (KMT2115SX) 🏆 Best Stainless Classic 2-slice toaster with manual high-lift lever (model KMT2115SX) • Extra-wide slots with self-adjusting racks for thick or thin slices • 5 shade settings on a dial Buy Now
Cuisinart CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster, White Cuisinart CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster, White 📐 Best Compact 2-slice compact plastic toaster (model CPT-122), white • 7 shade settings on a browning dial • 1.5-inch wide toasting slots for bagels and bread Buy Now
Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster 2 Slice, Extra-Wide Slots (MT-220 SS) Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster 2 Slice, Extra-Wide Slots (MT-220 SS) 🏆 Best for Artisan Bread 2-slice full stainless steel toaster (model MT-220 SS), by Mueller Austria • Long extra-wide 1.6-inch slots for artisan bread and bagels • 6 browning levels with LED display Buy Now
BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster, Black (T2569B) BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster, Black (T2569B) 💰 Best Budget 2-slice toaster, black (model T2569B) • Extra-wide slots, about 5.25 in long and 1.5 in wide, for thick bread and bagels • Shade selector dial (1-6 in the listing imagery) Buy Now

5 Recommended Toasters

Five research-based candidates compared on features and everyday use

We compared product identity and practical buying criteria from the current Amazon listings. No independent hands-on tests were performed. Confirm the exact variant, dimensions, and care instructions before ordering.

🏆 Best Overall

🌟 Key Features That Stand Out

  • ✓ 2-slice toaster, brushed stainless steel (model BTA720XL), 1000 watts
  • ✓ 'A Bit More' button adds extra toasting time mid-cycle
  • ✓ 'Lift & Look' lever checks progress without interrupting the cycle
  • ✓ LED indicator shows toasting progress
  • ✓ Bagel and Frozen functions plus Cancel
  • ✓ Wide slots for bagels and thick artisan bread

💡 Why We Recommend It

Breville fixed toasting's two annoyances — peeking and underdone — in one polished machine.

🎯 Best For

Ideal for picky toast eaters who want to check and adjust without starting over.
✅ Pros
  • ✓ 'A Bit More' button adds time mid-cycle
  • ✓ 'Lift & Look' checks progress without cancelling
  • ✓ LED progress indicator and wide slots
❌ Cons
  • ✗ Premium tier among these toasters
  • ✗ Brushed steel needs a wipe to stay smart
🏆 Best Stainless Classic

🌟 Key Features That Stand Out

  • ✓ 2-slice toaster with manual high-lift lever (model KMT2115SX)
  • ✓ Extra-wide slots with self-adjusting racks for thick or thin slices
  • ✓ 5 shade settings on a dial
  • ✓ Bagel and Cancel buttons with blue backlit illumination
  • ✓ Extra-deep steel toasting cavity for even browning
  • ✓ Stainless steel finish; removable crumb tray

💡 Why We Recommend It

KitchenAid's KMT2115 is the sturdy classic — deep cavity, self-adjusting racks, nothing gimmicky.

🎯 Best For

Ideal for households that want a solid metal toaster with simple, honest controls.
✅ Pros
  • ✓ Extra-wide slots with self-adjusting racks
  • ✓ Extra-deep cavity for even browning
  • ✓ Manual high-lift lever and backlit buttons
❌ Cons
  • ✗ 5 shade settings are the fewest here
  • ✗ No frozen setting listed beyond Bagel and Cancel
📐 Best Compact

🌟 Key Features That Stand Out

  • ✓ 2-slice compact plastic toaster (model CPT-122), white
  • ✓ 7 shade settings on a browning dial
  • ✓ 1.5-inch wide toasting slots for bagels and bread
  • ✓ Bagel, Defrost, Reheat and Cancel functions with LED indicators
  • ✓ Extra-lift carriage and removable crumb tray
  • ✓ Compact footprint, about 6.5 x 11 x 7 inches

💡 Why We Recommend It

The CPT-122 is the compact standard: seven shades, every core function, minimal counter space.

🎯 Best For

Ideal for small counters, dorms and anyone who wants the classic compact toaster in white.
✅ Pros
  • ✓ 7 shade settings — the finest control here
  • ✓ Bagel, Defrost, Reheat and Cancel with LEDs
  • ✓ Compact footprint and extra-lift carriage
❌ Cons
  • ✗ Plastic body feels lighter than the steel models
  • ✗ Product photo is a smaller listing image
🏆 Best for Artisan Bread

🌟 Key Features That Stand Out

  • ✓ 2-slice full stainless steel toaster (model MT-220 SS), by Mueller Austria
  • ✓ Long extra-wide 1.6-inch slots for artisan bread and bagels
  • ✓ 6 browning levels with LED display
  • ✓ Cancel, Defrost and Reheat functions
  • ✓ Self-centering slots
  • ✓ Removable crumb tray

💡 Why We Recommend It

Mueller's UltraToast is built around the long slot — artisan bread finally fits without trimming.

🎯 Best For

Ideal for bakery-loaf households — the long slots take slices other toasters refuse.
✅ Pros
  • ✓ Long extra-wide 1.6-inch slots
  • ✓ 6 browning levels with LED display
  • ✓ Self-centering slots and full stainless body
❌ Cons
  • ✗ Long-slot shape takes more counter depth
  • ✗ Newer model with a shorter track record
💰 Best Budget

🌟 Key Features That Stand Out

  • ✓ 2-slice toaster, black (model T2569B)
  • ✓ Extra-wide slots, about 5.25 in long and 1.5 in wide, for thick bread and bagels
  • ✓ Shade selector dial (1-6 in the listing imagery)
  • ✓ Bagel, Frozen and Cancel buttons
  • ✓ Self-centering slot guides
  • ✓ Drop-down crumb tray

💡 Why We Recommend It

BLACK+DECKER's extra-wide classic does the essentials at the friendliest tier — a rental and first-home staple.

🎯 Best For

Ideal for value buyers who need extra-wide slots for bagels and thick bread.
✅ Pros
  • ✓ Extra-wide slots, about 5.25 inches long
  • ✓ Bagel, Frozen and Cancel functions
  • ✓ Self-centering guides and drop-down crumb tray
❌ Cons
  • ✗ Basic dial-only shade control
  • ✗ Black plastic finish is the plainest here

🏆 Our Top Pick

After comparing all 5, our top recommendation is:

Breville BTA720XL Bit More Toaster, 2 Slice, Brushed Stainless Steel

Breville fixed toasting's two annoyances — peeking and underdone — in one polished machine.

The Breville 'A Bit More' is the toaster for people who care about toast — it fixes the peek and the underdone slice. The KitchenAid is the stainless classic, the Cuisinart the compact for small counters, the Mueller the artisan-loaf fit, and the BLACK+DECKER the wide-slot value standard.


Other Buying Guides: electric kettles · mini waffle makers · cold brew coffee makers

How to Choose a Toaster

  • Slot width: 1.5–1.6 inch slots (all five here) take bagels and thick slices; long slots (Mueller) take artisan bread lengthwise.
  • Shade control: more settings (Cuisinart's 7) mean finer browning steps; an LED progress display (Breville, Mueller) shows where the cycle is.
  • Mid-cycle fixes: Breville's A Bit More and Lift & Look solve the two classic toaster frustrations — underdone toast and checking without cancelling.
  • Lift height: high-lift levers (Cuisinart's extra-lift, KitchenAid's manual lift) keep small slices and fingers apart.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best 2-slice toaster? ▶
The Breville 'A Bit More' (BTA720XL) is our top pick: the A Bit More button, Lift & Look lever and LED progress indicator fix everything people dislike about toasters. The KitchenAid KMT2115 is the classic stainless alternative.
Why does my toast brown unevenly? ▶
Uneven browning usually comes from the first cycle of the day (elements start cold) and from bread thickness varying. Self-centering slots — on the Mueller and BLACK+DECKER here — keep slices equidistant from the elements, which is the main fix.
What does the bagel setting do? ▶
Bagel mode toasts the cut side more than the crust side (or extends time on simpler models). The Cuisinart, Breville, KitchenAid and BLACK+DECKER here all include a dedicated bagel function.
Can a 2-slice toaster fit artisan bread? ▶
Look for long or extra-wide slots: the Mueller's long 1.6-inch slots and the BLACK+DECKER's extra-wide slots (about 5.25 inches long) take bakery slices that standard slots reject.
How do I clean a toaster? ▶
Unplug it, empty the crumb tray (every model here has a removable or drop-down tray), and shake the toaster gently over the sink. Never use a knife inside a plugged-in toaster.